Search This Blog

Showing posts with label Divorce. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Divorce. Show all posts

Sunday, June 20, 2010

I Want Out: A Basic Guide to Getting a Divorce in New York

So, it took you a month to tell each other you were in love, a couple of years until he proposed, and a year to plan the wedding. But after all the cake was eaten and the mortgage payments were late, the bickering lasted too long and now you want OUT! It is an oft-quoted statistic that we've all heard, but nonetheless, about half to 60% of all marriages end in divorce (the rate is higher for second, third, fourth marriages and so on). Due to this fact, your questions are many and can be very urgent in light of the want to end the marriage quickly and painlessly, especially if children are involved.

All other states in the fabulous union of America have what is known as a "no-fault" divorce (for example "irreconcilable differences"). But the good ol' state of New York makes divorce a bit more difficult for its citizens. In New York there is no such thing as irreconcilable differences...there are only four grounds for divorce in New York and if your situation does not fit one of these, you cannot pass go and collect $250. The four grounds for divorce are: 1) Adultery; 2) Abandonment (one spouse abandons the home for at least one year); 3) Constructive Abandonment (no marital "relations" for at least one year...i.e., no sex); or 4) Cruel and Inhuman Treatment (which can mean anything from physical abuse to consistent emotional, mental abuse- and the allegations here must be very specific).

After establishing that you have grounds for a divorce, the next question is usually "how much will it cost?" The answer will obviously vary based on who you hire to do the job. My standard rates depend on whether or not a divorce is contested or uncontested. Many people come to me saying, "oh, it's definitely uncontested...we both want it over." However, whether or not both parties want out is not the only issue which will determine whether your divorce will really be considered uncontested. An uncontested divorce not only means you both agree the marriage is over...it means you agree as to whose "fault" it is, because NY state makes one person take the fault. However, I often advise my clients to take "fault" for the marriage's failure, unless the ground is adultery, which is still a crime in New York (and admitting adultery can affect a maintenance/alimony claim). Fault does not have a thing to do with who gets what, or custody and support issues.

In addition, to be uncontested, the parties in the divorce must also agree on who gets what...who gets the personal (actual belongings other than land/house) property and real (land/house) property; who gets the debt (any debt incurred during the marriage, regardless of whose name it's under, is MARITAL debt- yes, you heard me right); who will carry medical insurance for the children (spouses may not qualify for coverage under their former spouse's plan once their divorce is final); will one spouse get maintenance (formerly called alimony); will the life insurance policies be maintained, and who will be the benificiary; will they agree to divide the marital portion of their IRA, 401K or pension plan; etc, etc, etc... So, just because you both agree it's over, doesn't necessarily mean you're dealing with an uncontested divorce.

All of that being said, if a divorce is truly uncontested, I will usually charge a flat rate commensurate with the value of the assets and ability of a particular client to pay a retainer fee. If the matter is contested, the standard rate is $3,000 - $5,000 in initial retainer (plus filing fees which total about $350.00), billable at $300.00 per hour. What that means is that the $3,000-$5,000 is deposited with me, and as I do work, each hour of work is deducted from the deposit at the rate of $300.00 per hour. If the initial deposit gets used up, I ask that it be replenished, usually in increments of at least $1,000.00 per month. But all lawyers' prices will vary in this regard.

The next question most commonly asked is: How long will it take? Again, it depends. If it's truly uncontested, it will take about a week to get an index number (the number assigned to your divorce when the initial papers, or "summons and complaint" are filed), and then another week to draft the rest of the documents and meet with the parties (usually one party is unrepresented when I do truly uncontested divorces) to sign them. Upon sending the final documents and filing fees to the clerk, the Court has 90 days in which to sign off on the final documents and my clients (in uncontested divorces) never see the inside of a courtroom. The end. But in a contested divorce, the time it takes to finish a divorce really depends on the parties (and the attorneys) involved. As soon as everyone agrees, final documents can be drawn up, signed and submitted to the Court for the Judge's signature. But this process, if the parties have significant assets (and even bigger egos), can take years.

The best advice I can give someone trying to get a divorce is to deal with the important things first. If there are kids involved and custody and support are your main concerns, go to family court and file a custody petition and a support petition before you file for divorce. This way, when you get around to filing for divorce, you will already have custody and support orders in place and will be well able to deal with the other issues more easily and speedily. If anyone reading this post has more questions about divorce, email me (look in my profile information) and I'd be happy to shed some light on the subject for you. It's a shame that we don't get all the cards full of cash at the end of a marriage...that's when we truly need it!

Thursday, May 27, 2010

We've Come a Long Way, Baby - or Have We? Spousal Maintenance in the 21st Century

It's all about choice. For hundreds of years, women have fought and shed blood, sweat and tears to lay claim to the rights and choices that men have always had. The ability to be a part of the workforce, to vote, to be employed in any field of their choosing- even to become President and fight on battlefields. Why, now that we have made such tremendous strides in many of those areas, do many women still feel that it is necessary to seek spousal maintenance?

Some may argue that the true freedom is in choosing any employment, and women's studies majors would argue with me that one such choice is to work in the home raising a family and keeping house, which has for time immemorial been an unpaid and thankless job that is woefully undervalued in our world at large. Raising children and keeping house are both truly noble pursuits (if the woman in question is actually rising to the occasion) and are worthy of great praise. But when does the choice to stay home, especially once children are in school, become the right to collect spousal maintenance (alimony) if the marriage ends?

New York State Domestic Relations Law section (hereinafter DRL) 236(B)(6)(a) states the following: "...the court may order...maintenance in such amount as justice requires, having regard for the standard of living of the parties established during the marriage...." [Emphasis supplied] But what, exactly, does justice require? I have heard it said that the trend is that the courts are shifting away from awarding maintenace in divorce actions due to the increasing ability of women to become self-supporting, but this has not exactly been my experience.

This is a huge topic to take on in this limited amount of space, but some of the issues are these: If a woman has been home of her own choosing and has never sought employment, has she really helped to "establish" the standard of living of the parties during the marriage? Many argue yes, the old "behind every great man is a great woman" theory. Maybe. And sometimes men insist that their wives remain home with the children, and even after the children have entered school, to maintain an orderly and beautiful home so the hard-working husband can truly have a home that is his sanctuary- his haven. In those cases, perhaps there is more rationale behind wives seeking maintenance. After all, they have forsaken the opportunity to pursue education and career for the care of home and hearth at their husband's insistence. My real question is, does the request for maintenance in a divorce action simply perpetuate the longstanding prejudice against women that depicts them as helpless frail creatures who need supporting? Or is payment of maintenance one way of valuing work that has conventionally been "women's work" monetarily as it never has been in days past?

If a court decides that a woman should be paid maintenance following divorce, how much should she be paid, and how long should her ex-husband be forced to pay her? Should it matter who divorces whom? And especially in cases where women do have expertise in a particular field, or advanced degrees for that matter, should they still be granted maintenance? Some of the factors considered by the court are: the income and property of the parties; the duration of the marriage and the age and health of both parties; the present and future earning capacity of both parties; the ability of the party seeking maintenance to become self-supporting; reduced or lost lifetime earning capacity of the party seeking maintenance as a result of having foregone or delayed education, career opportunites, etc.; the presence of children of the marriage in the homes of the parties; the tax consequences to each party; contributions of the party seeking maintenance as a spouse, parent, wage-earner, and homemaker to the career potential of the other party; the wasteful dissipation of marital property by either spouse; and any transfer or encumbrance made in contemplation of a matrimonial action without fair consideration. (See New York DRL section 236B(6)(a)(1)-(10))

These factors leave a ton of wiggle room for judges, however, and the result, more often than not, is that even those spouses who are seemingly able to be self-supporting are awarded some form of maintenance if they have been married for any substantial length of time. In fact, in a recent case of mine, the wife was seeking maintenance for six years even though she held an advanced degree and there were no children of the marriage. In a conference in chambers with the judge's law clerk, she told me point blank that it is customary (at least in that court) for the amount of maintenance to be paid for approximately one quarter of the duration of the marriage. In that case the parties were married for twelve years, so maintenance, if ordered after trial, would probably be ordered to be paid for at least three years. This was a surprising mathematical formula that as far as I can see, cannot be found within the confines of the DRL. But such liberal discretion is afforded in this area that once custom is developed in a particular court, such custom is unlikely to be contradicted.

To be fair, occasionally, it is the husband who seeks spousal maintenance, but I have never had such a case, nor have I heard of one being handled by any of my peers. Those men are usually the ex-husbands of movie stars and female moguls...not work-a-day people. No, typically, women are the ones who want the state to intervene and tell their ex-spouse that there is a price on having had the privilege to be married to them, a price on bearing children and keeping house. Maybe that is as it should be. Though I can't help but wonder if in our struggle to progress we haven't actually regressed. The pendulum always swings too far and then comes sailing back in a reactionary rebellion to past practices. Are women simply selling themselves short, or is this really about placing monetary value on jobs that have traditionally been held by women and therefore have never really been recognized as work that is worthy of pay?

My mother's generation saw women who were able to come out from under their fathers' or husbands' thumbs and finally have the ability to make a successful career in a male dominated field of their choosing. But in the midst of the feminist haze did we lose what we were really after: The freedom to choose our futures? And are we losing more of that freedom by sacrificing to the gods of divorce law by suggesting that because we choose to be caregivers we must be subsidized by father government in the form of maintenance checks from ex-husbands? I am not offering an answer, but I believe it is most important to ask the questions.

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Location, Location, Location!

So, this installment has to do with an issue I have encountered frequently of late and am extremely passionate about: Relocation of a parent and the impact that has on custody and visitation.

By way of introduction to custody cases in general, I will set forth the roads open for pursuing custody and visitation rights. There are two ways in which to establish custodial/visitation and child support rights in any case. The first is to file for a divorce in Supreme Court and allow that Court to handle all of the issues surrounding the children of the marriage. The second way is to file a petition in family court for support and/or custody and visitation. The family court route is a better option for folks who have immediate issues or hotly contested custody issues that must be resolved quickly. Family Courts in New York have something called "standards and goals" which in plain english means that when a custody case has been ongoing for six months, the case is pushed by the court to either be settled or go to hearing (trial). This means a faster resolution of the case than is typical of Supreme Court litigation, which can potentially go on for years. Family court is also the ONLY option for less traditional families (i.e., moms and dads that never got married).

In cases where one spouse has threatened to leave with the kids at some point, there is usually much discussion over how far that spouse will be permitted to move from the other since moving will impact the non-custodial parent's visitation rights considerably. Often times, a "radius clause" is put into the settlement agreement, or is imposed on one party following a hearing for custody and visitation. This "radius clause" says that Jane must stay within, let's say for example, a thirty five mile radius of the current residence of Bob, or the residence the parties shared prior to separating. If Jane then violates the order, Bob now has sufficient grounds to file a violation petition.

In other instances, the custodial parent files what is known as a relocation petition which is essentially asking the court's permission to move out of state. Factors considered by the court include what kind of support system the custodial parent has, whether or not they can afford child care if no family members live nearby, and whether a better, more lucrative employment opportunity has been offered (or is available) in another state. If the court grants such a petition, the non-custodial parent's visitation is relegated to school vacation weeks and summers. In my opinion, this is a very sad situation wherein children are prevented from having the essential frequent contact with both parents that every child requires and deserves.

The problem occurs when the custodial parent does not ask the court's permission to leave the jurisdiction, but simply packs up the kids without warning and leaves the state, or sometimes, the country. This is a scary prospect and in cases where parents leave the country there is federal legislation prohibiting such "parental kidknapping" and providing penalties for doing so. But when a party leaves the state with the kids and the non-custodial parent has no money for private investigators and the like, the chances that an arrest warrant (if issued) will be executed in a diligent fashion are slim to none. These parents are basically out of luck and may never see their children until they reach adulthood.

Unfortunately, most of the parties who have custody are still women. I hate to betray my gender, however, I see it this way: Women are the first to point fingers at "deadbeat dads" and dads who don't have enough involvement in their children's lives; but it also seems to me that women feel a god-given right to just pick up and leave with children that it took two people to create. I understand the whole "I'm the one that carried them for nine months" argument, but perhaps our society as a whole needs to look at how the family court system glaringly favors women. Family Court slams the gavel and tells men to get more involved and with the same gavel allows women to use motherhood as an excuse for controlling how often, when and where men will be permitted to see the children they helped create. Equality means just that: EQUALITY I would love to see the day when men can file for custody and not have to prove that the mother is on drugs, beating the children or mentally insane to establish that they may in fact be the more stable parent. Something to chew on.

Monday, May 24, 2010

Unlawfully Wedded Strife

Perhaps you've witnessed the scene before: Husband and wife go from destined to be together to destined to kill one another. That's just a typical day in Family or Supreme Court when marrieds decide that "happily ever after" is more like Cinderella's carriage turning back into pumpkin at midnight! The questions is, when does household strife call for an Order of Protection?

Many people incorrectly use the term "restraining order" when what they are really referring to is known in the great state of New York as an Order of Protection (hereinafter "OOP"). It may seem like an outdated or sexist stereotype that primarily women are the ones who need protecting from abusive spouses, but by and large, the majority of petitioners seeking an OOP are still women. When a client calls to ask whether or not this is something she should be seeking during the course of an ugly divorce or custody proceeding, I proceed with the utmost caution.

The problem as I see it, is that in order to err on the side of caution, many courts seem to hand out OOPs like candy on Halloween. Don't get me wrong...it's CLEAR that for many women (and some men, lest I am criticized for generalizing) an OOP is a necessary instrument in safeguarding the physical and mental welfare of herself and and her children. But when is it simply a sword disguised as a shield??? In other words, are OOPs being handed out too frequently for alleged behavior that has caused these women neither danger nor fear of any kind? And are actual cases of abuse and battering being blurred or somehow trivialized due to the rising numbers of women who "cry wolf?"

This is a tricky and sensitive issue, and for many, because of their own very real and personal history of abuse, my words may seem harsh or unwarranted. But after seeing hundreds, maybe thousands of family court and divorce cases where the OOP is being used as a weapon, I am swayed that abuse is often exaggerated or wholly fabricated in order to gain a strategical advantage in a custody battle or divorce action.

There are two types of OOPs: Limited and Full. A Limited OOP (or LOOP) says that the person being charged must refrain from stalking, harassing, menacing, etc., the person who has sought the OOP. A Full OOP (FOOP) is also known as a "stay away Order," and it means just that. The person with a FOOP against them must stay at least "x" amount of feet from the petitioner/complainant's school, business, home, etc. The problem I see with such Orders is that often they are granted "ex parte" by the Judge, which means that Sally goes to the family court, files her emergency petition, and goes before a Judge where the person being accused is not even aware that such charges are being made against him (or her). Before you know it, the Officers come to get Sally's husband (or baby daddy, as the case may be), arrest him and tell him he has got to immediately get out of his home until further court proceedings occur. Due process? Not so fast...he must wait until another court date comes around (which can often be up to a month or so) so that the Judge and the Attorney for the Children (if there are children) can hear both sides and decide whether an immediate or real threat exists.

I am not against people in danger obtaining OOPs to attempt to protect themselves and their loved ones,but I will say that in my humble opinion ex parte OOPs are not needed nearly as often as they are granted. My general advice to a client calling me to ask if she should obtain an OOP...if you're not sure if you're really scared of him or in danger, then you probably aren't and should allow the legal process to unfold naturally, without muddying the waters with an OOP. Exaggerating your case will NOT help your case and in the end, you are doing harm to a system that was put in place for those who truly need such drastic intervention.